Mary Beth Kelly, Retired Justice, Michigan Supreme Court, joins JAMS as a 16 year veteran of Michigan courts, including serving on the Michigan Supreme Court from 2011 to 2015. Prior to joining Michigan’s highest court, she served as Chief Judge of the Wayne County Circuit Court for three terms, where she remains the only woman in history to hold the position. In private practice at a major Detroit firm, Kelly concentrated on commercial litigation, often in the class action context.
Kelly’s JAMS practice focuses on mediation/arbitration of complex, business/commercial matters and employment disputes. Her time on the bench provides unique expertise in the family law arena, particularly in high asset disputes which may involve business valuation issues. JAMS clients also look to Justice Kelly’s appellate experience for unbiased, confidential case evaluations, allowing them to fine-tune arguments for matters on appeal, reassess settlement options, manage client expectations—and ultimately proceed with heightened confidence and a winning strategy.
ADR Experience and Qualifications
Ms. Kelly has extensive experience as an advocate, judge and arbitrator in the following areas:
- Administrative Law
- Civil Rights
- Family Law
- Administrative Law
- Arbitrator in a dispute concerning the construction, supply and maintenance of an energy contract. Authored acclaimed dissent in Detroit Edison Company v. Department of Treasury, 498 Mich 28, (2015) (Analysis of energy industry in Michigan and tax consequences); Found a city nuisance demolition ordinance comports with substantive and procedural due process in Bonner v. City of Brighton, 495 Mich 209 (2014) (authored).
- Litigated many antirust and trade class action matters; authored important trade opinions, including LaFontaine Saline v. Chrysler Group LLC, 496 Mich 26 (2014) (Rejecting argument for geographical limitations in new markets based on letter of intent).
- Regularly consults and evaluates appeals; participates in mock arguments for all levels of appellate practice.
- Arbitrated and mediated various commercial and contractual disputes, including: arbitrator in a breach of contract action concerning the provision of financial services for banking institutions; arbitrator in dispute between OEM and supplier; arbitrator in real estate dispute; mediator in dispute between OEM and supplier.
- Facilitated an employment dispute concerning a university and an employee. Authored landmark employment decisions, including Henry v. Laborers’’ Local 1191, 495 Mich 260 (2014) (Whistleblowers’ Protection Act claims preempted by the National Labor Relations Act and must be tried before the National Labor Relations Board); Whitman v. City of Burton, 493 Mich 303 (2013) (Plaintiff’s motivation not relevant under Whistleblowers’ Protection Act); and Hamed v. Wayne County, 490 Mich 1, (2011) (analysis finding no respondeat superior liability for sexual harassment under Civil Rights Act)
- Family Law
- Settled and mediated hundreds of cases while presiding over a domestic relations state court docket. Particularly qualified to evaluate high asset estate and business valuations.
- Government/Public Agency
- Facilitated numerous disputes, including disputes with bargaining units, over funding and other public issues.