Judge Thomas McPhee (Ret.) brings to JAMS more than 40 years of legal experience, including 22 years on the Thurston County Superior Court. He has tried nearly every type of case imaginable, earning a reputation for being one of the hardest working jurists in the region. Judge McPhee conducted more than 300 settlement conferences and required dispute resolution in all civil cases assigned to him. At JAMS he serves as a mediator, arbitrator, and special master with experience administering disputes regarding electronically stored information.
Judge McPhee has extensive experience with business and commercial matters. As a lawyer, he represented corporations, associations, and owners in such diverse fields as construction, health care, and mobile home retail sales. He tried business and commercial cases in state and federal courts. As judge and JAMS neutral, his experience includes shareholder disputes, insurance disputes, accounting matters, breach of contract cases, franchise matters, and licensing disputes. Judge McPhee has considerable experience with tax matters, as the court where he sat has exclusive jurisdiction for most state tax refund claims and constitutional challenges to state taxation laws.
- Mediated breach of contract claim by insurance agency involving sale of agent’s “book of business”, including issues of standard of conduct, confidentiality, and trade secrets.
- Arbitrated breach of contract claim against auto dealer group involving stock options and bonuses.
- Mediated claim for breach of contract to merge two engineering firms, involving contract interpretation and performance, collusion, and misappropriation of trade secrets.
- Mediated claim for breach of contract to administer and conduct SuperFund cleanup site, involving contract interpretation and environmental legal standards.
- Mediated claim for years of fraud and misappropriation involving auto dealer’s accounting and inventory records.
- Mediated shareholder dispute between engineering firm and engineers, whose companies had merged, involving issues of payment and quality of work.
- Mediated dispute between insurance agency and broker over terms of contract buy-out.
- Mediated dispute among partnership groups for largest supplier of electronic equipment to Alaska fishing and crabbing industry, with business locations in Seattle and Dutch Harbor. Claims involved failure to account, fraud, and money laundering.
- Mediated dispute over collapse of joint venture and merger between two architectural/engineering firms, involving collusion, interference with business, and accounting fraud.
- Mediated cases involving dissolution and liquidation of closely held corporations, including sub-S liabilities and buyouts – e.g., dissolution of a tech startup, involving issues of distribution of partially finished intellectual properties.
- Mediated claim for municipal sales tax refund by national telecommunications company regarding municipal sales tax on telecom services. Case involved agreement to trade credits for services over a period of time to avoid municipal budget crises.
- Adjudicated a wide range of breach of contract cases and construction warranties, many involving public agencies – e.g., jury/bench combined class action trial against state DSHS for breach of contract resulting in judgment exceeding $50 million. Case turned on implied warranties and contract provisions. Affirmed on appeal.
- Adjudicated cases related to two distinct types of franchise claims:
- Private claims between franchisor and franchisee, mostly for breach of contract or specific performance – e.g., claim by food industry franchisees for fraud, alleging a pyramid scheme by franchisor;
- Enforcement actions brought by government agencies for violation of Washington franchise law – e.g., claim by state insurance commissioner alleging auto warranty franchisor’s alleged violation of state insurance and franchise laws.
- Extensive experience as judge for enforcement of state licensing laws, primarily professional or public safety related licenses. My court in the state capital has exclusive jurisdiction over many of these actions.
- Adjudicated a joint venture dispute among three groups of individual partners and their shell corporations arising from a joint venture to import batteries and construct regulators to power electric cars. Claims involved breach of contract, accounting fraud, and conversion of import licenses.
- Adjudicated dispute among family member-partners in multi-state auction business. Issues centered mainly on business valuation and accounting.
- Adjudicated the constitutionality of the taxing scheme for construction of Safeco Field, home of the Seattle Mariners.
- Adjudicated tax refund claim brought by operators of intermodal freight operations at the Port of Seattle, involving the taxation of giant cranes at the port.
- Administered claim of negligent investment of state pension funds. Pretrial management of massive accounting records discovery issue.