David F. Crow, retired Judge of the 15th Judicial Circuit, served over thirteen years as a judge in Palm Beach County, Florida, with more than ten years in the Civil Division. During his tenure, he served as Administrative Judge of the Civil Division for two years and presided over thousands of civil matters, both jury and non-jury, including professional negligence, tobacco Engle progeny, construction, product liability, real property, employment, discrimination, personal injury, and complex business disputes among others. In his thirteen years on the bench, Mr. Crow was consistently rated as one of the top judges in the 15th Judicial Circuit in bar associated polls.
Prior to his appointment to the bench, he practiced as an attorney for over 28 years, with the last 25 as a founding member and shareholder of Paxton, Crow, Smith, Bosso-Pardo & Davis P.A. in West Palm Beach, Florida. His practice concentrated in the areas of personal injury, wrongful death, and insurance coverage, including products liability, professional negligence, construction litigation, premises liability, negligent security, road defect litigation, and all forms of automobile/truck accidents. He is board certified by the Florida Bar in Civil Trial Practice and has substantial experience litigating complex economic and catastrophic injury claims. Also, Mr. Crow prepared the majority of appellate matters for his firm resulting in 25 published opinions.
ADR Experience and Qualifications
Prior to appointment to the bench:
- Board Certified Civil Mediator
- Certified Arbitrator pursuant to Florida Rules of Civil Procedure 1.810
- Arbitrator on numerous panels pursuant to Florida statutes and pursuant to arbitration provisions in insurance policies
- Mr. Crow presided over thousands of contested matters and has significant experience handling complex civil cases including:
- Thirteen-week medical malpractice jury trial involving six defendants and twelve Fabre defendants. Over eight hundred jurors were interviewed prior to the seating of the jury. The case also involved several Frye hearings and orders (pre-Daubert) as to the scientific reliability of the plaintiff's theory of causation.
- Multi-week, complex medical malpractice jury trial involving catastrophic neurologic birth injury. Significant and complex issues including respondeat superior, the corporate negligence doctrine, admissibility of physician disciplinary records, as well as apparent agency. The trial resulted in a verdict in excess of 30 million dollars for the plaintiff.
- Consolidated multi-week catastrophic injury and wrongful death products liability cases against the manufacturer of a personal watercraft. The cases involved complex legal, evidentiary, and factual issues concerning the alleged lack of off-throttle steering in personal watercraft.
- Multi-week non-jury trial involving an attorney fee dispute between "PIP" attorneys and "Bad Faith" attorneys over ten million dollars in attorney fees from a 14.5 million dollar settlement. The appellate court quoted Mr. Crow as the trial judge, advising that the litigation could be characterized as a "case study for a course on professional conduct involving multi-party joint representation agreements and the ethical pitfalls surrounding such agreements when the interests of some of the attorneys and/or their clients come into conflict."
- Presided over the conclusion of a complex twenty-year litigation concerning agreements as to the ownership of two large commercial shopping centers. This included a jury trial based upon breach of contract and fraud, a non-jury declaratory action interpreting the terms of the purchase agreements, profit participation agreements, management agreements, and two separate non-jury accounting trials.
- Mr. Crow also has substantial experience litigating or presiding over numerous contested civil matters including:
- Business Commercial: Breach of contract, complex business economic claims, commercial foreclosure, fraud, partnership, business and shareholder dissolutions, mechanic liens, declaratory judgments, and unfair and deceptive trade practices
- Class Action/Mass Tort: Tobacco Engle progeny cases
- Construction Defect: Residential, commercial, and road construction
- Employment: Discrimination (age, gender, race, handicap claims), non-compete, trade secrets, sexual harassment, whistleblower, and wrongful termination
- Insurance: First party, bad faith claims, coverage, contract disputes, and declaratory actions
- Personal Injury/Torts: Auto/truck, toxic tort, and environmental tort litigation, defamation, product liability, fraud, arson, uninsured/underinsured motorist, premises liability, negligent security, wrongful death, infant neurological damage claims, and watercraft accidents including admiralty claims
- Professional Liability: Architectural, engineering, legal, and medical
- Real Property: Commercial and residential claims, boundary disputes including statutory or common law way of necessity and/or easements, lease, purchase and sale disputes, and condemnation